2022...that plan to transfer Polish MiG-29s to Ukraine....

ImageForum for news and discussions on miltary aviation matters.

Forum rules
Image
Post Reply
User avatar
Stratofreighter
Scramble Master
Scramble Master
Posts: 22190
Joined: 25 Jan 2006, 08:02
Location: Netherlands

2022...that plan to transfer Polish MiG-29s to Ukraine....

Post by Stratofreighter »

...this may become a long saga /long story, after all / eventually... :? :|


And apart from the transfer,
how long would it take for these MiGs to be destroyed on the ground
by air attacks
on the precious few suitable hardened strips
available in Ukraine
to operate these Fulcrums at all? :roll:

Highway operations cannot be conducted for long.
And the Russians probably know all the suitable air strips already.

I do see that the Polish government would really like to have some
extra well-maintained capable secondhand F-16s
on very favourable financial terms... :roll:

...on with the news...

https://edition.cnn.com/2022/03/08/poli ... index.html
Pentagon says Polish proposal to transfer jets to US to give to Ukraine isn't 'tenable'

Updated 0050 GMT (0850 HKT) March 9, 2022

The Pentagon on Tuesday evening dismissed
Poland's proposal floated hours earlier to transfer its MiG-29 fighter jets to the United States for delivery to Ukraine.

Pentagon press secretary John Kirby said in a statement that the Pentagon did not believe Poland's proposal was "tenable,"
just hours after Polish officials released a statement
saying the government was ready to deploy
all of its MiG-29 fighter jets to US Air Force's Rammstein Air Base in Germany
so they could then be provided to Ukraine in its fight against Russia.


"It is simply not clear to us that there is a substantive rationale for it," Kirby said.
"We will continue to consult with Poland and our other NATO allies about this issue
and the difficult logistical challenges it presents,
but we do not believe Poland's proposal is a tenable one."


Kirby said that the decision about transferring Polish-owned planes to Ukraine was
"ultimately one for the Polish government,"
adding that the proposal shows the complexities
that the issue presents as Russia has made threatening statements
over arms being provided to Ukrainians for use against Russian forces.

The idea as laid out by Poland was too risky, Kirby said,
as the US and NATO seek to avoid an outright conflict between the alliance and Russia.

"The prospect of fighter jets 'at the disposal of the Government of the United States of America'
departing from a U.S./NATO base in Germany to fly into airspace
that is contested with Russia over Ukraine raises serious concerns for the entire NATO alliance," Kirby said.

Biden administration caught off guard

The Defense Department statement was released Tuesday evening
after the Polish proposal caught the Biden administration completely off guard, multiple sources told CNN.

While Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky has pleaded for more aircraft amid the Russian invasion,
the offer had not been discussed with the US before making it public
and Polish officials did not bring it up with Secretary of State Antony Blinken
when he was recently in Poland either.

US officials have privately weighed sending aircraft to Ukraine
but have repeatedly noted the difficult logistical challenges of doing so.

Poland's surprise announcement complicates what had already been a high-stakes visit by Vice President Kamala Harris,
who is due to land in Warsaw late Wednesday.


Harris had been expected to discuss the fighter jet issue while in Poland, according to officials.

The White House had previously said it was in discussions with the Polish government
about a plan for Poland to supply Ukraine with its Soviet-era fighter jets
and the US to backfill the planes with F-16s.

Harris is still scheduled to depart Wednesday morning for Poland,
but now there are intensive conversations within the administration
about how to work with Poland to come to some sort of agreement that allows the jets to reach Ukraine.

A top State Department official said Tuesday
that Poland did not consult with the United States prior to issuing its statement.

"I saw that announcement by the government of Poland as I was literally driving here today,"
Undersecretary of State for Political Affairs Victoria Nuland said
during a Senate Foreign Relations Committee hearing.


Nuland noted that the US and Poland have been in consultations for a couple of days on the possibility,
but added she had come to the hearing directly from a meeting "where (she) ought to have heard about."

"So I think that actually was a surprise move by the Poles," Nuland told lawmakers.


'Ready to deploy'
The Polish government said in a statement Tuesday that it is "ready to deploy -- immediately and free of charge --
all their MiG-29 jets to the Ramstein Air Base
and place them at the disposal of the Government of the United States of America."

"At the same time,
Poland requests the United States to provide us with used aircraft with corresponding operational capabilities.
Poland is ready to immediately establish the conditions of purchase of the planes," the statement said.

Speaking to US lawmakers virtually on Saturday,
Zelensky asked for American support to facilitate the transfer of Soviet-era fighter jets from Eastern European nations to Ukraine,
where pilots have been trained to fly them
and could use them to attempt to control the skies as Russia conducts its war against the country.


By Saturday evening, US and Polish officials were in discussions about a potential agreement
to supply the country with American F-16 fighter jets
in exchange for Poland sending its Russian-made jets to Ukraine.

"We are working with Poland as we speak to see if we can backfill anything that they provide to the Ukrainians,"
Blinken said on CBS on Sunday.

"But we also want to see if we can be helpful in making sure that,
whatever they provide to Ukrainians,
something goes to them to make up for any gap in the security for Poland that might result."


On Monday, a Pentagon spokesman said the Department of Defense was in
"interagency" discussions to "examine" the possibility of the US sending fighter jets to other European countries
if those countries choose to send fighter jets of their own to Ukraine.


Prior to the apparent dismissal of Warsaw's proposal by the Biden administration,
members of Congress appeared supportive of the move.

During Tuesday's Senate Foreign Relations Committee hearing,
Democratic Sen. Ben Cardin asked Nuland
to ensure the Biden administration notifies Congress if there are going to be any delays getting F-16s to Poland.

Two European diplomats told CNN on Tuesday, prior to the Pentagon statement,
that the complicated logistics behind the idea of Poland giving the jets to Ukraine
had not yet been finalized.


The Polish announcement came after some Polish officials expressed frustration
about how forward leaning the US was on this subject over the weekend, the sources said.


"In fact, we're talking with our Polish friends right now about what we might be able to do to backfill their needs if,
in fact, they choose to provide these fighter jets to the Ukrainians.

What can we do?
How can we help to make sure that they get something to backfill the planes
that they're handing over to the Ukrainians?

We're in very active discussions with them about that," Blinken said Sunday.

A Polish official told CNN they believed Harris' trip would be a good time for the US
to announce more details about aircraft transfers,
but the Pentagon statement suggests such a possibility is unlikely.


Other countries that are in talks with the US about taking part in similar transfers are conducting the conversations quietly,
without raising expectations, said a central European diplomat.
https://edition.cnn.com/2022/03/08/poli ... index.html
November 2024 update at FokkerNews.nl....
User avatar
SquAdmin
Scramble Master
Scramble Master
Posts: 3743
Joined: 21 Feb 2003, 11:04
Location: C a/d Y

Re: 2022...that plan to transfer Polish MiG-29s to Ukraine....

Post by SquAdmin »

Stratofreighter wrote: 09 Mar 2022, 08:52 how long would it take for these MiGs to be destroyed on the ground
by air attacks
on the precious few suitable hardened strips
available in Ukraine
to operate these Fulcrums at all? :roll:

Highway operations cannot be conducted for long.
And the Russians probably know all the suitable air strips already.
Despite having an advanced weapons arsenal at their disposal, the Russians have not managed to knock out all airports yet. Their cruise missiles prove to be less accurate than what was initially expected and strike aircraft don't seem to stray very far into Ukrainian territory.
Greetz,

Patrick
User avatar
michel N
Scramble Master
Scramble Master
Posts: 2633
Joined: 06 Oct 2002, 14:31
Subscriber Scramble: MN

Re: 2022...that plan to transfer Polish MiG-29s to Ukraine....

Post by michel N »

Some of the Antonovs that flew to Bydgoszcz, flew back to Ukraine later (through Stuttgart). And although they didn’t fly far across the border, it makes clear Russia has no air superiority over all of Ukraine. So for any aircraft the Ukraine Air Force still has, all hope is not lost yet.
flown in: Things with wings
Chrissly69
Scramble Senior
Scramble Senior
Posts: 420
Joined: 23 Mar 2014, 13:17

Re: 2022...that plan to transfer Polish MiG-29s to Ukraine....

Post by Chrissly69 »

Don't see a problem. Strange however the polish communicate this in the open... Is it to ensure they will get the F-16's?
User avatar
Stratofreighter
Scramble Master
Scramble Master
Posts: 22190
Joined: 25 Jan 2006, 08:02
Location: Netherlands

Re: 2022...that plan to transfer Polish MiG-29s to Ukraine....

Post by Stratofreighter »

...Tattle Lounge is not far away as far as this topic is concerned, indeed... :twisted: :wink:
At least it will not clog up the other Ukraine-topics :roll:

The remarks at
https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/4 ... to-ukraine
are very much "food for thought"...
November 2024 update at FokkerNews.nl....
User avatar
SquAdmin
Scramble Master
Scramble Master
Posts: 3743
Joined: 21 Feb 2003, 11:04
Location: C a/d Y

Re: 2022...that plan to transfer Polish MiG-29s to Ukraine....

Post by SquAdmin »

Chrissly69 wrote: 09 Mar 2022, 10:16 Don't see a problem. Strange however the polish communicate this in the open... Is it to ensure they will get the F-16's?
It's most likely to show the world they are willing to dispose of their MiG's for Ukraine's sake, but leave the responsibility to actually get them over the border to the US.
Greetz,

Patrick
User avatar
Alpha Kilo One
Scramble Master
Scramble Master
Posts: 4496
Joined: 25 Apr 2005, 16:17
Type of spotter: F5
Subscriber Scramble: Jein 😉

Re: 2022...that plan to transfer Polish MiG-29s to Ukraine....

Post by Alpha Kilo One »

Doesn't seem to materialize though....

https://edition.cnn.com/2022/03/08/poli ... index.html

Pentagon says Polish proposal to transfer jets to US to give to Ukraine isn't 'tenable'

(CNN)The Pentagon on Tuesday evening dismissed Poland's proposal floated hours earlier to transfer its MiG-29 fighter jets to the United States for delivery to Ukraine.
Pentagon press secretary John Kirby said in a statement that the Pentagon did not believe Poland's proposal was "tenable," just hours after Polish officials released a statement saying the government was ready to deploy all of its MiG-29 fighter jets to US Air Force's Rammstein Air Base in Germany so they could then be provided to Ukraine in its fight against Russia.
"It is simply not clear to us that there is a substantive rationale for it," Kirby said. "We will continue to consult with Poland and our other NATO allies about this issue and the difficult logistical challenges it presents, but we do not believe Poland's proposal is a tenable one."

Kirby said that the decision about transferring Polish-owned planes to Ukraine was "ultimately one for the Polish government," adding that the proposal shows the complexities that the issue presents as Russia has made threatening statements over arms being provided to Ukrainians for use against Russian forces.

The idea as laid out by Poland was too risky, Kirby said, as the US and NATO seek to avoid an outright conflict between the alliance and Russia.
"The prospect of fighter jets 'at the disposal of the Government of the United States of America' departing from a U.S./NATO base in Germany to fly into airspace that is contested with Russia over Ukraine raises serious concerns for the entire NATO alliance," Kirby said.
Biden administration caught off guard
The Defense Department statement was released Tuesday evening after the Polish proposal caught the Biden administration completely off guard, multiple sources told CNN.
While Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky has pleaded for more aircraft amid the Russian invasion, the offer had not been discussed with the US before making it public and Polish officials did not bring it up with Secretary of State Antony Blinken when he was recently in Poland either.
US officials have privately weighed sending aircraft to Ukraine but have repeatedly noted the difficult logistical challenges of doing so.
Poland's surprise announcement complicates what had already been a high-stakes visit by Vice President Kamala Harris, who is due to land in Warsaw late Wednesday.
Harris had been expected to discuss the fighter jet issue while in Poland, according to officials. The White House had previously said it was in discussions with the Polish government about a plan for Poland to supply Ukraine with its Soviet-era fighter jets and the US to backfill the planes with F-16s.
Harris is still scheduled to depart Wednesday morning for Poland, but now there are intensive conversations within the administration about how to work with Poland to come to some sort of agreement that allows the jets to reach Ukraine.
A top State Department official said Tuesday that Poland did not consult with the United States prior to issuing its statement.
"I saw that announcement by the government of Poland as I was literally driving here today," Undersecretary of State for Political Affairs Victoria Nuland said during a Senate Foreign Relations Committee hearing.
Nuland noted that the US and Poland have been in consultations for a couple of days on the possibility, but added she had come to the hearing directly from a meeting "where (she) ought to have heard about."
"So I think that actually was a surprise move by the Poles," Nuland told lawmakers.
'Ready to deploy'
The Polish government said in a statement Tuesday that it is "ready to deploy -- immediately and free of charge -- all their MiG-29 jets to the Ramstein Air Base and place them at the disposal of the Government of the United States of America."
"At the same time, Poland requests the United States to provide us with used aircraft with corresponding operational capabilities. Poland is ready to immediately establish the conditions of purchase of the planes," the statement said.
Speaking to US lawmakers virtually on Saturday, Zelensky asked for American support to facilitate the transfer of Soviet-era fighter jets from Eastern European nations to Ukraine, where pilots have been trained to fly them and could use them to attempt to control the skies as Russia conducts its war against the country.
By Saturday evening, US and Polish officials were in discussions about a potential agreement to supply the country with American F-16 fighter jets in exchange for Poland sending its Russian-made jets to Ukraine.
"We are working with Poland as we speak to see if we can backfill anything that they provide to the Ukrainians," Blinken said on CBS on Sunday. "But we also want to see if we can be helpful in making sure that, whatever they provide to Ukrainians, something goes to them to make up for any gap in the security for Poland that might result."
On Monday, a Pentagon spokesman said the Department of Defense was in "interagency" discussions to "examine" the possibility of the US sending fighter jets to other European countries if those countries choose to send fighter jets of their own to Ukraine.
Prior to the apparent dismissal of Warsaw's proposal by the Biden administration, members of Congress appeared supportive of the move. During Tuesday's Senate Foreign Relations Committee hearing, Democratic Sen. Ben Cardin asked Nuland to ensure the Biden administration notifies Congress if there are going to be any delays getting F-16s to Poland.
Two European diplomats told CNN on Tuesday, prior to the Pentagon statement, that the complicated logistics behind the idea of Poland giving the jets to Ukraine had not yet been finalized.
The Polish announcement came after some Polish officials expressed frustration about how forward leaning the US was on this subject over the weekend, the sources said.
"In fact, we're talking with our Polish friends right now about what we might be able to do to backfill their needs if, in fact, they choose to provide these fighter jets to the Ukrainians. What can we do? How can we help to make sure that they get something to backfill the planes that they're handing over to the Ukrainians? We're in very active discussions with them about that," Blinken said Sunday.

A Polish official told CNN they believed Harris' trip would be a good time for the US to announce more details about aircraft transfers, but the Pentagon statement suggests such a possibility is unlikely.
Other countries that are in talks with the US about taking part in similar transfers are conducting the conversations quietly, without raising expectations, said a central European diplomat.
"Nix bliev wie it es"
User avatar
Key
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 11250
Joined: 06 Dec 2002, 09:21
Type of spotter: F2
Subscriber Scramble: U bet
Location: ex EHAM

Re: 2022...that plan to transfer Polish MiG-29s to Ukraine....

Post by Key »

The part that isn't tenable is this of course:
fighter jets 'at the disposal of the Government of the United States of America' departing from a U.S./NATO base in Germany to fly into airspace that is contested with Russia
as it would mean that NATO were directly engaging the Russian Federation. But that doesn't need to be (and will hopefully never be) the case at all. In fact, I was surprised to read this interpretation as I assumed from the start Poland was just looking for a transfer location.

As said before, there is no difference in principle, merely just in 'visibility', between weapons deliveries already going on and the delivery of 4th generation fighter jets to Ukraine. If it happens, they would have to be operated by Ukrainian forces from Ukrainian soil - just like the other weapons systems. The mentioning of Ramstein might be based on nothing more than it being the largest USAF base in Europe, while thinking of a transfer location.

Poland obviously feels enormous pressure in many ways. Huge amounts of refugees put a social and economical strain on it, that has really just begun. If Ukraine should ever fall under Russian control, that would at least double the political and military pressure felt from that side by this country already bordering Belarus and Kaliningrad. Handing more assets to Ukrainian defence while at the same time have an intermediate fleet update itself would be a perfect deal for Poland. It appears some officials were just trying to speed up the process. After all, the intent has full support, as secretary Blinken already said in a an intervies some days ago, that CNN quoted:
"In fact, we're talking with our Polish friends right now about what we might be able to do to backfill their needs if, in fact, they choose to provide these fighter jets to the Ukrainians. What can we do?"
Erik
Climb to 20ft, we're leaving a dust trail
Post Reply

Return to “Military Aviation News”